Share this article on Facebook
No Such Thing as Bad Publicity: New Authors can benefit from Critics and Detractors
by Antonio Graceffo
A writing professor once gave us this example.
What if Charles Dickens had written the best novel in the universe, and then put
it away in a drawer? The answer obviously was that we would never have heard of
him. And, the lesson the professor wanted us to learn was that the writers work
doesnt end when we complete the final chapter. We have to continue with next
step, which is getting published.
But, unfortunately, the professor should have
continued with the example. What if, after Charles Dickens published his work,
no one read it? That is the position many new authors find themselves in. When
they began writing, they believed that the odds were so severely stacked against
them; being published was so unlikely, that they had no plans beyond this
seemingly impossible dream.
If you ask a promising athlete, "What is your
dream, in life?" He will answer, with no hesitation, "I want to win a gold medal
in the Olympics." But, if you ask him the next question, he will probably
stutter. "The Olympics will be held on a Tuesday. What are you planning to do on
Behavioral psychologists, particularly working
with athlete and business people, have long taught us that we set our own
limits, the glass ceiling, which we cant over come. Success or failure is
completely determined by what we are thinking. Because I have been both a
salesman and an athlete, I have been trained to visualize my success. In my
mind, there is a picture of a very long difficult road, ending at a distant
finish line where my books would be published.
If you have been living by a similar
visualization, my suggestion would be, to extend that visualization beyond
having a book published. After you cross that finish line, another very long and
bumpy road begins, leading to your book becoming a financial success.
The way you get people to buy your book is by
getting people to talk about your book. Conventional ways of doing this include,
asking newspapers and magazines to write reviews, donating copies to libraries
and schools, doing talks and book signings, and buying media ad space. Of course
you can increase your book sales by publishing articles about related subjects.
Once you have a reputation for being an expert in your field, people will buy
your books. New ways of getting people to talk about your books is to go on
Internet forums and chat rooms, and start a conversation about your
At least once a week, I do my fame check. I put
my name into all of the Internet search engines and see what people are saying
about me. The strongest indicators are when you find reviews and chats which
were done independent of any action by you.
We all love getting good reviews. They are a
boost to the ego, and help us along the long path of constant rejection, which
is the life of the professional writer. But what about the bad reviews? What if
you go in a chat room and find out that someone has panned your book? It can be
disheartening. But, as writers we are leaving ourselves open to criticism. Other
professions can hide their feelings. A policeman may disagree with the laws he
is forced to enforce. A teacher may oppose a school policy. A business executive
may think his boss is a jerk. But, they would never say this in public, because
they would lose their job. At the risk of sounding cynical, most people can live
a life of denial and then, switch their outer face, when the wind of public
opinion changes direction. But, writers lack this option. Our job is all about
expressing our feelings and opinions. If we try to hide our true self, our
writing will suffer. And, regardless of what opinions you have written on paper,
your true feelings will show through.
People will always have opinions. And no matter
how good you are, at least 10% of the people will dislike you. Believe it or
not, but somewhere, there is a bitter man, who hates Mother Teresa, because he
feels she was just too selfish.
So, how does a writer deal with negative
reviews? The only way we can survive in this business, without resorting to
substance abuse or suicide (i.e. Jack London, Jack Kerouack, Ernest Hemingway,
Hunter S. Thompson...) we must learn to turn adversity into opportunity. Bad
publicity may be bad, but it is publicity.
You get paid when people buy your book. And, you
get the same money if they hated it or loved it. Obviously, we like hearing
praise on our writing, and word of mouth advertising is often the best way to
sell books. There are so many books available in bookstores and online, we often
chose the ones recommended by a friend. Sales statistics for other types of
products and services suggest that if people are satisfied with a product, they
will tell two people. If they are dissatisfied they will tell ten.
Only a small percentage of
people who liked a book or article will write a letter to the editor. But people
who hated it always write. And worst of all, a lot of people with too much time
on their hands are bitter people. They might be sick, injured, unemployed, or
incarcerated, and have nothing to fill their day, beyond writing hateful letters
of complaints to editors and authors.
It is normal human behavior that we spend more
time talking about things we dont like, than talking about things we
A satisfied customer might say, "I ate at that
new Thai restaurant last night, and I liked it. The food was good. The prices
were fair. And the waiters gave excellent service."
But, the dissatisfied customer will say, "You
will not believe what happened to me last night. I tried out that new Thai
restaurant, and, from the minute I walked in, everything went wrong. The waiter
" The dissatisfied customer will launch into a tirade, spinning a
narrative tale, with conflict, plots, sub-plots, and maybe even space aliens.
Hemingway, on his best day, couldnt tell a story as well as a dissatisfied
customer. The satisfied customer, on the other hand, only talked about the
restaurant for two seconds.
After the satisfied person gives his short
review, the listener says, very noncommittally, "Ill have to try that place."
After the dissatisfied customer finishes his lengthy and entertaining saga, the
listener says, because he believes he is expected to, "I better stay away from
that place." But in the back of his mind, he is thinking, "It couldnt be that
bad. Id better go find out for myself." Or, maybe he is thinking about the
dissatisfied customer, "That guy is such a complainer. If he didnt like it,
its probably good."
One friend pours himself a glass of milk from
the refrigerator, and quickly spits it out. "Its spoiled!" He yells. The other
friend takes sip, also spits it out, and shouts. "Youre right!" Then he calls
to someone in the other room, "Come try this milk, its spoiled."
You see the worst movie of your life, and call a
friend. "I hated the new Vanna White movie." The friend says, "But I told you it
was bad, why did you go see?" You give some feeble excuse like. "I wanted to see
In popular culture, and this extends to books,
there is a certain shock factor which helps sell books. Most of us werent
interested in reading a book, with the title, Satanic Verses, until we
heard that the author had to go into hiding, because of death threats. Then, it
became a best seller. In Southeast Asia, where I live and work, there is a book
about Cambodia, called Off the Rails in Phnom Penh. Almost immediately
after publication, the book was debunked, as a mixture of exaggerations and
sensationalism. And, since the author conducted much of his research in
brothels, and while buying and taking drugs, the book raises a number of moral
questions. If you mention this book in a group of ex-pats, anywhere in
Indochina, most will say they hated it. But more importantly, nearly 100% of
them will say that they have read it. And the ones who havent read it, will say
something like, "I have been meaning to read that, to see why everyone hated it
Someone once said that you could judge a man by
his enemies. If someone important or famous hates your book, this is almost a
prescription for success. Charlton Heston probably didnt give favorable reviews
to Michael Moors "Bowling for Columbine."
I enjoyed "The Ten Commandments" as much as the
next guy, but I still paid $12 to watch the movie.
The truth is, I dont think it does. Most
Kerouack fans know of the famous review by Truman Capote. After he read Off
the Road, he said "Thats not writing, thats just typing." But, I dont
know of a single person who cites this quote as a reason for not reading On
the Road. "If Truman Capote didnt like it, I wont read it."
In my field, of adventure travel writing, one of
the most famous literary rivalries of all time was between Eric Newby and
explorer Wilfred Thesiger. Thesiger was a brilliant man, hardened by years of
privation, exploring the deserts of Africa and Central Asia. During a brief
meeting in the Hindu Kush, he once called travel writer, Eric Newby, a pansy,
for sleeping on an inflatable mattress. The story of this silly insult has been
retold so many times, it will probably outlive any of the great works written by
either man. When Thesiger died, last year, I went on line, gathering as many of
his obituaries as possible. At least half of them mentioned the fact that he had
crossed Africas Empty Quarter more than once, and called Eric Newby a
Both men are heroes to me. And, once again, I
dont believe that this insult put anyone off of reading Eric Newby.
As writers, our jobs are to entertain, to
inform, and to provoke critical thought.
I just received a threatening email, telling me
that ten people are on line 24/7 writing bad reviews of my books. Paul Theroux,
my biggest literary competitor, has only 61 reviews on amazon.com, soon, I will
If someone famous thought enough about you to
hate you, you should feel flattered. And, if they went the extra mile, and wrote
a scathing criticism of your work, glow in the spotlight. Fame and financial
success will not be far off.
© Copyright 2005, Antonio Graceffo
Adventure writer Antonio Graceffo is originally from Brooklyn, New York. He has a reputation as an aggressive, judgmental, and
provocative author, who writes humorous and insulting books about Southeast Asia. Widely panned, his books are available at amazon.com. He presently lives in Cambodia, but will be fleeing the country before the publication of his controversial book, Letters from the Penh. (Letters from the
Penh will be available on amazon.com in 2006) Antonio_graceffo@hotmail.com
Other articles by Antonio Graceffo :
Check out the latest articles in
How to Promote Your Book BLOG
Find out what works.
Join the Writing for DOLLARS! group on Facebook.
Writing for DOLLARS!
is a publication of